Help me choose a guest design?!

UPDATE: And the WINNER IS???? #2. Thanks everyone for your input!!

I can't think about our new house without my mind wondering to decor. How am I going to decorate it?? For the most part we are using everything we already have (red couches, dark wood, slate blue, brown and moss-dark greens). But that still leaves one bedroom and bath completely empty. These rooms will be for guests till we have kids, then we will add a nursery (classic Winnie-The-Pooh) to the bedroom.

Empty doesn't work for me so I wasted all day yesterday trying to figure it out and I ended up with 4 different looks. Hubs likes #2 and 3 but says it's my choice and I keep going back and forth. Can you look at them and help me decide???? Here they are (everything is from Walmart, Target, Ikea or Kirkland's - trying to keep the price as low as possible):

We don't really care about having it match the rest of our house. We just want something that will make us smile when we see it, and something our guests will feel comfortable in.

Which, of the four options, should I choose??